Peter Taylor - the new Chris Morris?
Every so often I feel moved to send in comments on BBC programmes; sadly I have yet to have one selected for their site, and my comment on Monday’s The New Al-Qaeda was no exception (Update: my comment subsequently appeared on the site). The first part of Peter Taylor’s series was BBC documentary at its worst: shallow, sensationalist and deeply flawed. For the programme to have been any more tabloid, it would have had to have been presented by a Page 3 Stunna, offering the chance to win £10,000 in a bingo game at the end.
As the majority of comments chosen by the BBC could have come straight from the Daily Mail’s letters page, I might as well post the one I submitted (perhaps not the greatest critique ever written, but what the heck!):
Whereas The Power of Nightmares provided an informative, intelligent analysis of the current Islamist threat and its origins, this was nothing more than dumbed-down terror-porn masquerading as insightful documentary. No amount of “edgy” camera angles could disguise the fact that the majority of the programme was taken up with tabloid-style stating of the obvious (wow, who’d have thought that bad people sometimes use the internet too?). Taylor’s unquestioning interviews with US military officials and self-proclaimed security experts never challenged any of their assertions. A year to research? I could have come up with a more informative documentary in a week.
Elsewhere, John Lettice provides a pretty thorough (and amusing) debunking of much of the programme in his review for the Register, and Spy Blog discusses some of the serious legal implications of the documentary.
Incidentally, I recently started reading Al-Qaeda: The True Story of Radical Islam by Jason Burke, and highly recommend it to anyone looking for intelligent analysis of the subject.
